What Are the Big Four in Edinburgh Fringe? (And Are They a Big Deal?)

What Are the Big Four in Edinburgh Fringe?

The Edinburgh Festival Fringe is famously open access, with "anyone—literally anyone—" able to perform if they can find a venue. Yet, within this anarchic, democratic framework, a few key players have emerged to dominate the scene. These are the "Big Four," a group of venue operators who hold immense sway over the festival's programming and brand. For a newcomer, they can seem like the only game in town. But who are they, what do they represent, and is their prominence a good thing for the festival’s soul?   

The Kings of Comedy's Castle

The term "Big Four" is an adopted label for four venue operators that have a long history at the Fringe and operate multi-room complexes, often across multiple sites. They are:   

• Assembly

• Gilded Balloon

• The Pleasance

• Underbelly

These venues "dominate the programming" and are a fantastic starting point for a newcomer trying to make sense of the festival's vast schedule. They tend to specialise in comedy and even controversially tried to rebrand themselves as the "Edinburgh Comedy Festival" in 2008. This action highlights a fundamental tension at the heart of the Fringe: the conflict between its grassroots origins and its evolution into a massive, commercial, and professional industry. The festival was founded by eight uninvited theatre groups. The Big Four, by contrast, "carefully curate" their selections  and have become powerful brands in their own right. Their existence reflects the evolution of the Fringe from a purely grassroots event to a complex, multi-layered industry.   

Meet the Big Four

Each of the Big Four has a distinct brand identity and a unique legacy that shapes the Fringe experience for performers and audiences.

Venue	Founded	Brand Identity / Specialisation
Assembly	1981	Oldest of the Big Four. Known for launching internationally acclaimed shows and its sprawling complex at George Square.
Gilded Balloon	1986	"Comedy Central." Unofficial home of Australian comedy. Known for its late-night show Late’n’Live and the So You Think You’re Funny? competition that launched careers like Peter Kay's and Lee Mack's.
Pleasance	N/A	Home to large-scale productions, improv shows like Showstoppers!, and a variety of international acts. Located in the Old Town.
Underbelly	2000	Known for the "offbeat and the unusual" and its "iconic purple cow shaped tent". Home to late-night variety shows and comedy galas in Cowgate and George Square.

Assembly is the oldest of the Big Four, tracing its roots back to 1981. It operates a massive number of venues and has launched internationally acclaimed shows like    

The Shark is Broken. Its operation is so vast that it is "three times the size of the rival Edinburgh International Festival".   

Gilded Balloon, founded by Karen Koren in 1986, is often called "comedy central". It is an institution, known for its "So You Think You're Funny?" competition, which has launched the careers of comics like Rhona Cameron, Dylan Moran, and Peter Kay. The research notes that its legendary late-night show,    

Late’n’Live, was a "dangerous, combustible collision of beer-y, boozy crowds and beer-y, boozy, genius comedians". The Gilded Balloon is a brand that is deeply woven into the fabric of comedy history.   

The Pleasance is a multi-purpose complex that hosts everything from large-scale musicals to international cabaret acts. It is known for its wide variety of programming and its large-capacity venues, making it an ideal choice for the curious and adventurous Fringe-goer.   

Underbelly is perhaps the most visually distinct of the Big Four, with its iconic purple cow-shaped tent. Founded in 2000, it is the youngest of the group but has quickly become known for championing the "offbeat and the unusual". It is a hub for late-night shows and a great place to see something completely different.   

A World Beyond the Big Four

The narrative of the "Big Four" is a prominent one, but it overlooks the vast and diverse ecosystem of the Fringe. While they hold significant power, they are not the only shows in town. Other multi-room operators, such as theSpaceUK and C venues, are massive forces in their own right, with theSpaceUK actually hosting the largest number of shows in 2019.   

The existence of the "Free Fringe," run by promoters like PBH and Laughing Horse, further debunks the idea that the Fringe is solely dominated by these large commercial entities. The Free Fringe exists as a direct counter-cultural response to the rising costs for performers, and it represents a return to the festival's founding principles. This is a crucial understanding that goes beyond a simple list of venues. The true Fringe experience is about exploring this ecosystem in its entirety, from a polished, carefully curated show in a Big Four venue to a raw, spontaneous free show in a tiny pub.   

So, What Are the Big Four in Edinburgh Fringe? In conclusion, the Big Four are undeniably a big deal. They are the gateways for many first-timers and the launchpad for countless careers. They have professionalised the festival and are a testament to its success. However, their prominence is a narrative that should not overshadow the vibrant, independent, and free scene that makes the Fringe what it is. The joy of the festival lies in a person's ability to appreciate the polish of a Big Four show while still seeking out the hidden gem in a tiny, independent venue.

Catch the best comedians off the London Comedy Circuit by buying tickets to our shows on the main page